24 October
2008

The Globe and Mail newspaper released their Canadian University Report. Like all such surveys, the results need to be taken with a BIG grain of salt, in part because it was based on students judging their own university (so there is a lot of selection bias). Similarly, note that most Americans who have never been outside the USA think it's be best country to live in: what does that really tell us?

Still, it's nice that McGIll University did well. Also interesting is the fact that Canadian students everywhere are generally satisfied with just 7% saying otherwise. This is consistent with my longstanding belief that the Canadian education systems works really well from both a social and personal point of view.

McGIll is most naturally compared to the University of Toronto, University of Alberta, UBC and Waterloo based on the size, diversity, scope and impact of the schools. This is especially true in Computer Science.

McGill is top in this set of 5 in the important areas of:


academic reputation,
campus atmosphere,
career preparation,
campus technology,
libraries,
student residences,
most satisfied students,
quality of education,
quality of teaching.



McGill fails to win in


course availability/variety,
student faculty interaction.


There were also some areas I personally deemed of minor significance like
buildings and facilities (where McGill still won), Food Services and ease of course registration (where it fared less well). Notably, the University of Western Ontario also fared very well in this survey.

In the area of "reputation", the entire set of "Large Schools" rank as follows:

McGill University

University of Toronto - St. George

University of Waterloo

University of Western Ontario

University of Alberta

McMaster University

University of British Columbia - Vancouver

Université Laval

Université de Montréal

University of Ottawa

Concordia University BUniversity

of Manitoba

Université du Québec

Ryerson University

York University

University of Calgary



Asking students about their own university becomes more questionable as the school becomes more culturally selective and/or smaller. For example, imagine asking people if their own rooms are well decorated, or if their church is the "best kind". For larger diverse universities this seems less problematic, since the students may have been exposed to a variety of alternatives.

By Gregory Dudek at | Read (2) or Leave a comment |    
Comments
Re: Globe's Canadian University Report: McGill, Toronto, Waterloo, UBC

yay for McGill

Posted by: foo at October 26,2008 14:29
Re: Globe's Canadian University Report: McGill, Toronto, Waterloo, UBC

I am a university of Toronto graduate and I like to see it fare better in results

Posted by: Jobs in Toronto at October 14,2010 13:43
Trackbacks
Please send trackback to:/blog/141/tbping
There are no trackbacks.
Post your own response

Each comment is manually screened for the presence of appropriate and substantive content, due to a constant onslaught of comment-spam. This means there may be a delay before your comment appears.


(Some kind of name is required, will be visible)

Required, whatever you enter will be visible to other users.


(Optional, used for "mailto" link)

Your email address is not required, but if you insert it it will be displayed so people can contact you.

Answer this question correctly to demonstrate that you are not a dumb spambot.



The title for your comment.



Your comment goes here. All relevant comments are welcome, except for those that simply promote an irrelevant product or else are used to fraudulently inflate the link count to an irrelevant web page. They appear after moderation. Don't forget to also fill in the captcha below or your text will be rejected automatically!

You must answer this question to prove you are human
which has the least friendly public image: 1:collie, 2:beagle, 3:doberman, 4:dachsund, 5:dalmatian?

Answer this question correctly to demonstrate that you are not a dumb spambot.